loading page

Current restrictions on access to NHS-funded fertility treatment exclude the majority of those trying to conceive: a retrospective cohort analysis
  • +4
  • Bríd Ní Dhonnabháin,
  • Tharni Vasavan,
  • Lucinda Lawrie,
  • Katherine Stack,
  • Sarah Norcross,
  • Natalie Getreu,
  • Helen C. O’Neill
Bríd Ní Dhonnabháin
Hertility Health Limited

Corresponding Author:[email protected]

Author Profile
Tharni Vasavan
Hertility Health Limited
Author Profile
Lucinda Lawrie
Hertility Health Limited
Author Profile
Katherine Stack
Hertility Health Limited
Author Profile
Sarah Norcross
Progress Educational Trust
Author Profile
Natalie Getreu
Hertility Health Limited
Author Profile
Helen C. O’Neill
University College London Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Institute for Women's Health
Author Profile

Abstract

Objective: Evaluate NHS-funded fertility treatment policies across England, Scotland, and Wales, assessing their alignment with the needs of those trying to conceive and comparing eligibility against NICE guidance. Design: Review of current NHS-funded fertility treatment policies and retrospective analysis of participant data. Setting: Not applicable. Population: Reproductive-age UK-based women using Hertility Health services from 2021-2023, focusing on those actively trying to conceive (TTC) or planning future pregnancies. Methods: Policy evaluation and data review without interventions. Main Outcome Measures: Eligibility for NHS-funded fertility treatment under UK regional policies versus NICE guidance. Results: In total, out of 2980 individuals actively trying to conceive and 6282 individuals planning for future pregnancies, 1700 (57.0%) and 2750 (43.8%) respectively would be ineligible for state-funded treatment under current regional policies: 1551 (57.7%) in England, 123 (53.2%) in Scotland, and 26 (41.9%) in Wales for those actively trying to conceive, and 2558 (43.9%), 146 (41.7%), and 46 (44.2%) for those planning future pregnancies respectively. In contrast, only 248 (8.3%) of those actively trying to conceive and 149 (2.4%) of those planning for future pregnancies would be ineligible if the NICE guidance were universally applied. Conclusions: By imposing outdated clinical and non-clinical qualifying criteria, the current NHS-funded fertility treatment policies exclude a substantial number of individuals requiring treatment. This necessitates a swift policy overhaul, as promised in the 2022 UK Women’s Health Strategy, to avoid further age-related fertility loss in women who require treatment imminently.
13 Sep 2023Submitted to BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
15 Sep 2023Submission Checks Completed
15 Sep 2023Assigned to Editor
15 Sep 2023Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
22 Oct 2023Reviewer(s) Assigned